Judge Torres Rejects Ripple SEC Motion on XRP Case Terms
By: bitcoin ethereum news|2025/05/16 17:15:05
0
Share
Judge Torres rejects Ripple-SEC motion to lift XRP injunction and cut civil penalty Court cites procedural flaws and failure to show public interest in proposed deal Legal experts expect revised motion, new brief required before case returns to appeal U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres has denied a joint request from Ripple Labs and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that aimed to change XRP case terms in their ongoing legal case. The motion, which was originally filed on May 8, sought to remove a permanent injunction on Ripple’s institutional XRP sales and reduce the company’s civil penalty from an initial $125 million down to $50 million. Judge Torres, however, issued a court order on May 15 rejecting this proposal. Her decision cited procedural deficiencies and a failure by the parties to adequately justify how the proposed changes would serve the public interest. The SEC’s attempt to renegotiate settlement terms comes after leadership changes within the agency, including the resignation of former Chair Gary Gensler. SEC’s Shift in Approach Met with Procedural Scrutiny Under its new leadership, the SEC has reportedly adopted a different approach to digital asset enforcement, showing a willingness to reduce penalties or resolve high-profile cases such as the one involving Ripple. The revised agreement proposed by Ripple and the SEC included dropping the appeal concerning secondary XRP sales and modifying the penalties related to violations from Ripple’s institutional sales. Related: SEC and Ripple Strike Settlement: What’s Inside the New Deal? Despite this mutual agreement between the two parties, Judge Analisa Torres refused to approve their request. In her order, she noted that Ripple and the SEC had not met the necessary legal standard required to lift the existing injunction. Furthermore, she found they had not sufficiently explained why modifying the terms would be in the public’s interest, especially considering her earlier findings. Next Steps: Refiling with Proper Legal Justification Expected Legal experts suggest that this rejection by Judge Torres stemmed primarily from the incorrect use of court procedure rather than a fundamental denial of the settlement’s potential terms. According to attorney Fred Rispoli, both Ripple and the SEC failed to apply the appropriate legal rule for their request. He indicated they will now need to refile using the correct legal process. Pro-XRP attorney John Deaton stated that both parties had sought an “indicative ruling” from Judge Torres. This was to determine if the court would likely approve the revised terms if the case were remanded from an appeal. However, the judge’s order clearly pointed out the necessity for a formal briefing. This briefing must outline why lifting the injunction on Ripple’s institutional XRP sales aligns with her earlier court finding that these sales indeed violated securities laws. Following the court’s decision, Ripple and the SEC must now submit a detailed joint brief that justifies the proposed changes to the settlement. John Deaton estimates that achieving a resolution through this revised process could still take several months. Related: Ripple-SEC Deal Looks Real, But Timing Is Weird, Legal Expert Warns Once Judge Torres receives a new, correctly filed motion and is satisfied with the provided legal rationale, the case is expected to return to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals before any final settlement can be approved. Disclaimer: The information presented in this article is for informational and educational purposes only. The article does not constitute financial advice or advice of any kind. Coin Edition is not responsible for any losses incurred as a result of the utilization of content, products, or services mentioned. Readers are advised to exercise caution before taking any action related to the company. Source: https://coinedition.com/ripple-sec-xrp-case-judge-torres-rejects-settlement-motion/
You may also like

The craziest Ethereum L2: L2 built by AI agents spontaneously organizing
This idea seems crazy, but it is not impossible.

Pantera Capital: How has Crypto as a Service affected us?
If you are planning to start a business in 2026, my advice is simple: Instead of just talking about technology, focus more on how you can solve real-world problems.

Pantera Capital: What changes have we made when crypto is treated as a service?
If you are planning to start a business in 2026, my advice is simple: stop talking excessively about technology and focus more on the actual problems you can solve.

Wall Street Shorts ETH: Vitalik is aware and has front-run, while Tom Lee remains oblivious
"The Ethereum token economic model has collapsed, wake up and see this clearly."

Social Capital CEO: How Equity Tokenization is Reshaping Capital Markets from US Stocks to SpaceX?
Equity tokens represent the next challenge: can tokenization expand from payments to ownership of financial assets?

CoinGecko Report: Surge of 346% vs Dip of 20.8%, The Wild Rise of DEX
A large-scale capital migration driven by platforms such as Hyperliquid towards decentralized infrastructure from centralization.

a16z: The Real Opportunity of Stablecoins Lies Not in Disruption but in Filling Gaps
The opportunity for stablecoins lies with those merchants that have yet to emerge.

Mining Exodus: Someone Holds $12.8 Billion AI Order
Mining Farms are Turning to AI Hashpower with no Turning Back.

March 6 Market Key Intelligence, How Much Did You Miss?
1. On-chain Funds: $16.3M USD has flowed into the OP Mainnet today; $13.7M USD has flowed out of Arbitrum
2. Largest Price Swings: $XPT, $AIX
3. Top News: Vitalik Calls on Ethereum Community to Shift Mindset, Uphold Core Principles, and Rethink Application Design "From Scratch"

a16z: The True Opportunity of Stablecoins is in Complementing, Not Disrupting
The stablecoin opportunity lies with those merchants yet to come onboard.
Predict LALIGA Matches, Shoot Daily & Win BTC, USDT and WXT on WEEX
The WEEX × LALIGA campaign brought together football excitement and crypto participation through a dynamic interactive experience. During the event, users predicted matches, completed trading tasks, and took daily shots to compete for rewards including BTC, USDT, WXT, and exclusive prizes.

Ray Dalio Dialogue: Why I'm Betting on Gold and Not Bitcoin
Gold is the only asset with a long-term history that can be transferred, is not easily replicable, and does not rely on anyone else's promise. Most currencies, debts, stocks, etc., are just promises of someone honoring their purchasing power.

Who Took the Money in the AI Era? A Must-See Investment Checklist for HALO Asset Trading
A one-page paper listed a series of questions about the potential impact of AI progress. Looking back over two years later, these questions appear particularly prescient, although none of them provided a definitive answer at the time.

Wall Street Bears Target Ethereum: Vitalik In the Know Takes Flight, Tom Lee Remains Bullish
「The Ethereum Tokenomics Has Collapsed, Wake Up and Realize It」

Pump.fun Hacker Steals $2 Million, Receives 6-Year Prison Sentence, Opts for 'Self-Detonation'
Life of Talent, Paranoia, and Setbacks

6% Annual Percentage Yield as Musk Declares War on Traditional Banks
A black metal card, 600x rate delta.

36 years, 4 wars, 1 script: How does capital price the world in conflict?
When the cannon fires, 10,000 ounces of gold. In a turbulent era, the wealth choice of the common people.

Mining Companies' Great Migration: Some Have Already Secured $12.8 Billion in AI Orders
Mining companies turn to AI computing power, with no turning back.
The craziest Ethereum L2: L2 built by AI agents spontaneously organizing
This idea seems crazy, but it is not impossible.
Pantera Capital: How has Crypto as a Service affected us?
If you are planning to start a business in 2026, my advice is simple: Instead of just talking about technology, focus more on how you can solve real-world problems.
Pantera Capital: What changes have we made when crypto is treated as a service?
If you are planning to start a business in 2026, my advice is simple: stop talking excessively about technology and focus more on the actual problems you can solve.
Wall Street Shorts ETH: Vitalik is aware and has front-run, while Tom Lee remains oblivious
"The Ethereum token economic model has collapsed, wake up and see this clearly."
Social Capital CEO: How Equity Tokenization is Reshaping Capital Markets from US Stocks to SpaceX?
Equity tokens represent the next challenge: can tokenization expand from payments to ownership of financial assets?
CoinGecko Report: Surge of 346% vs Dip of 20.8%, The Wild Rise of DEX
A large-scale capital migration driven by platforms such as Hyperliquid towards decentralized infrastructure from centralization.